This needs a prequel. The prologue of True North by Q.K. Petty was so intriguing and interesting, I couldn’t wait to read the rest. While I enjoyed the story, and hope that there are more to this series, there was so much that was unexpected (and one point that was I think supposed to be a twist but was able to see coming from a mile away; but that’s ok – it was still totally worth the read). I would think that the opening piece about St Peter’s chains would have made a terribly interesting story in and of itself. I didn’t expect to just into the 21st century from there. And I certainly didn’t expect Mobile Alabama to be the setting for a story about a secret society who seeks out religious artifacts to prevent them from starting cults, or wars. NYC, sure. Alabama, nope!
The mix of mystery and religion and science was reminiscent of Angels and Demons by Dan Brown. The violence and brutality was more reminiscent, however, of R.F. Kuang (the Poppy Wars specifically). There was certainly a fair bit of killing and torture and I cringed while picturing the gruesome scenes painted by the author. And before you ask, yes, those are both books that I liked very much (well, the first of the Poppy Wars anyway).
My criticism is in the laissez-faire manner in which some of the characters treat what is supposed to be this big secret – the existence of their “society”. It feels that as an element, that was underdone. To have no concern for the fact that Orion tells all his friends right away – its playing a little loose with the rules that would most certainly be integral to the fabric of any secret society… I also think there should have been more to Eden’s and Orion’s relationship – we really don’t see much of it for all the time they spend together.
As for the plot – there must be more going on. While there was a lot of action and the plot moved surprisingly fast, I did latch onto the set-up from the prologue about the purpose, and purported not so great nature, of the House of David. And yet, there isn’t really anything in the main story to satisfy the craving that was set up by the prologue. But, it feels like there is at least one more coming because it certainly ended on a cliff hanger.
The characters were interesting and the story was fairly unique for something that has a Warrior Nun (season 1) feel to the it – with the religious undertones – and it sets up the question of is religion really science in disguise, or is it the other way around with some of the twists and tiny bits of science that drip throughout. Warrior Nun is a good comparison for a number of reasons – e.g., Divinium, the crown of thorns, the Halo, Shield of Faith… – as artifacts go, and the story here certainly finds similarities, but in all the good ways. I thought Warrior Nun was awesome and it’s almost like this book could occur in the same universe. I can imagine Eden running some offshoot of the Order that is not just nuns, but maybe reports to them? How cold would that be?
I am eager to read the next – I couldn’t put this one down – would really like to know what happens to Orion. Can he be saved from his reaction to being tortured? Will he and Eden find out more about their father? Will they be able to be brothers? Will they stop the evil they are facing (and which organization is really the evil here)? I do hope there is a sequel (Goodreads lists this as “#1” of “A Series of Four Seasons” and the cover says “Book One” so I take it there will be more, but I am unable to find more info to confirm it). For anyone who likes religious mysteries, secret societies, artifacts with power, and questions about religion vs science, this is worth the read!